FMT Letter: A step forward towards a standard FMT protocol for IBS (Oct 2023) Magdy El-Salhy et al compare their procedure to a recent RCT that got poor results

Fecal Microbiota Transplants

Michael Harrop

Active member
Jul 6, 2023

TABLE 1. Handling of the donor's faecal transplant.

Yau et alEl-Salhy et alComments
Handling of the donor faecesExposed to ambient air 2 h before deliveryFroze immediately and kept frozen until transplantationExposing faecal samples to ambient air reduces the abundance of important commensal taxa. Freeze–thaw faecal samples does not affect the viable bacterial composition of stool9
Transplant preparationMixed in a laboratory blenderMixed manuallyThe increased air flow by high-speed blending may result in increasing oxygen exposure and be more detrimental to oxygen sensitive species than manual homogenisation9

The issues discussed above could explain the difference between FMT without effect and FMT with high efficacy according to the stringent EMA/FDA composite responder endpoints.

I think it's more likely to be a donor quality issue.
Format correct?
  1. Yes