Her son needed a fecal transplant for a fearsome C. diff infection. Getting one required a tortuous journey. Stricter FDA stool bank rules made the treatment harder to find (Mar 2026) FMT 

Fecal Microbiota Transplants

Michael Harrop

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 6, 2023
Messages
1,518
Location
USA
https://www.statnews.com/2026/03/23/c-diff-fda-drug-approval-access-paradox-fecal-transplants/

Her son had been sick for four months when Blanca Morales started asking about a transplant. It had started with a case of strep throat from Mundo’s first-grade class — routine enough, treatable with antibiotics. Then he started having stomach trouble.

The illness had likely been sparked by strep-fighting antibiotics back in March 2025, the bacterial community of Mundo’s colon wiped out, allowing the heartier, toxin-spewing C. diff to proliferate — a microscopic strongman taking advantage of a microbial power vacuum.

At the end of 2024, the Food and Drug Administration had halted shipments from a major supplier of fecal transplant material, a national stool bank called OpenBiome. That left kids like Mundo with fewer options. “It shouldn’t be this hard to cure a child,” Morales said.

But then in 2022 and 2023, two companies secured FDA approval for human-excrement-derived drugs to prevent C. diff. recurrence. But the two drugs weren’t approved for kids, the immunocompromised, or those whose C. diff is severe.

They were also expensive, often far more than a transplant. According to First Databank, Vowst’s list price is $19,680 for 12 pills and Rebyota’s is $9,411 for one enema bag. Insurers sometimes balked at covering them even for the intended patients. The denials were only more vociferous at the idea of using them off-label for someone like Mundo. An FDA approval was supposed to protect patients — and in theory, make effective treatments more accessible. In the real businessy world of American health care, that wasn’t always how it worked out.
The compromise made some at the agency squirm, worried it would set a slippery precedent. “It’s hard to put the genie back in the bottle,” said one former FDA employee.

They squirmed even more one year later when the founders of OpenBiome started a commercial company called Finch Therapeutics, and competitors cried foul. It was true that OpenBiome charged hospitals only for its materials, as cost recovery, and framed its work as temporary, bridging the gap until a treatment got FDA approval. But the spinoff caused some to view its activities as not entirely altruistic.
The doctor gave Morales two options, Morales recalled. The first was for Mundo to stay on antibiotics from age 7 to 12, and if clinical trials were still running in about four years, he could enroll then. The other option was Vowst, the medication made from some of the bacterial spores found in an FMT.

Four more years of antibiotics made Morales nervous. But she also knew that Vowst was only FDA-approved for adults.

She mentioned the fact that it’s off-label use for children, and the chances of my insurance approving it were really, really low

She was on the highway when the insurer called a few days later, driving to the mechanic. “They said, ‘We would like to let you know that we received your appeal, but the trustees have told us that you’ve already appealed this, and they denied you a couple of times. They had an outside gastroenterologist look at this, and they decided that your medication is not medically necessary,’”

A few days after that, Mundo’s Vowst prescription was approved.
The old version of enforcement discretion is unlikely to return for FMT, though there’s been an administration change and many of the officials involved in closing that loophole in 2024 are no longer at the agency.
 
Format correct?
  1. Yes
Back
Top Bottom