This was prompted by a recent discussion of Xifaxan and SIBO, and reading Michael's early experiences. I have also posted about experiences with Xifaxan/rifaximin and vancomycin before. It became clear that if we're going to talk about antibiotics as a possible booster to FMT that we need to be very specific about timing in relation to FMT. I also have learned something with regards to antibiotic interaction with oral transplants in particular (which may also well hold for FMT) due to an (unplanned) antibiotic course this past year that is worth sharing.
There are essentially four phases relative to microbiome transplants that I have ever taken antibiotics. When I talk about effects, I will be referring to short (2 week or less) courses unless stated otherwise. Long (6 months to a year or longer) courses are NEVER a good idea for the microbiome regardless of timing, and are rarely if ever prescribed by reputable doctors:
1. Months to years before any FMT.
Back before I had chronic health issues, these had some minor temporary side effects, but no lasting effects good or bad. At least no noticeable ones. Some studies have shown effects in lab animals like propensity toward obesity, so one cannot state with certainty that they are totally benign, but these are risk factors that only show up with large "n". I didn't have significant gut problems until after a long period of continuous antibiotics. After that point, multiple short courses of rifaximin did nothing at all. Michael noticed significant worsening during a short course near the beginning of his chronic illness journey, but minimal side effects, and some temporary improvement during later courses.
Thus, I'd say the "verdict" on this is, not chronically ill --> minimal overt effects, while chronically ill --> worsening until microbiome is "ruined", then no effect or a small, temporary benefit. It's worth mentioning the small group of people with near miraculous response to rifaximin, some of whom maintained it for months to years after, from the original SIBO studies. I suspect these were patients who had experienced relatively small and brief microbiome "insults", in fact it was common knowledge at the time that many of them had developed IBS following a bout of food poisoning, which is usually a few-day, self-limiting disease.
2. Immediately preceding a FMT.
This is what I have been calling "pretreatment". What distinguishes this from the previous is that there is not enough time for the microbiome to reach a new equilibrium after discontinuing the drug before new microbes are added in. This requires stoppage at most a week before FMT, probably less, but also at least 24 hours before FMT. Most common seems to be a 1-3 day gap. Also, nearly everyone uses vancomycin for this, not just "random" other antibiotics, and certainly not systemically absorbable ones, which could be important. And some protocols give a colon prep the day before FMT, which given the previous point likely helps flush out remaining antibiotic.
This is the timing that I have seen a significant number of researchers suggesting improves FMT. And it was what I did before my most successful FMT yet, in 2015.
Again, this is stopped prior to FMT. The minute you first introduce a new donor's microbes into your body, you are now in the third phase.
3. Immediately following a FMT (or other transplant). This includes in the middle of a multi-dose transplant.
Contrary to the previous phase, which is the most likely to be helpful, this is by far the most likely to be detrimental. And it's not just antibiotics that could be a problem here, really any unusual (for you) risky behavior is to be avoided. I suspect that after my first FMT an unraveling was instigated by relatively minor cannabis usage.
This is the vulnerable "critical period" that will determine how strong and lasting your success from a transplant will be. This is absolutely NOT the time to get impatient and "greedy", trying to desperately wring more benefit out of a transplant or accelerate the timeline of improvement. Even if you feel newly invincible from the transplant, you almost certainly aren't. Also it's too premature to judge the full extent of the benefit yet anyway, so the need for any further treatment isn't clear. I would recommend taking a several month complete hiatus from the field of medicine if it's possible. Unless your transplant actually made you WORSE--then by all means do whatever, because you're going to need more transplants later anyway.
So, to be brief, do not do this!
4. Long-term after a transplant
This applies to the experience when, approximately a year after my first and most successful FMT, a short course of rifaximin temporarily restored some of the benefit I had lost in the intervening year. Since this was the only course to show such a benefit, it suggests that it was only because some of the microbes from the FMT were still around, and that killing off some dysbiosis newly acquired in the intervening year allowed them to "show through". This strengthens my suspicion that the patients in the SIBO trials who improved had experienced damage too mild and brief to cause much "missing microbes".
The major question that remained after all of this was when the boundary is between phases 3 and 4. I may have partly narrowed this down inadvertently this year due to a minor surgical procedure I needed, that unfortunately required antibiotics. First there was an antibiotic drip during the procedure itself, I don't know what antibiotic I ended up getting (I could probably find out if it ends up being important). Then there was a 5-day course of TMP-SMX afterward, which I finished as directed. I would have preferred to avoid this procedure but I had an issue bad enough to affect lab results and not doing it could have caused long-term problems, of which I didn't need more.
This procedure was almost exactly 6 months after my first oral transplant from Donor 4, who you can read about here: https://forum.humanmicrobiome.info/threads/experience-so-far-with-oral-microbiome-transplant.1359/. In the intervening time I had tried a re-treatment with Donor 4, about 3 months after the first and three months prior to the procedure, with no further improvement. Also, a new donor entered the picture, Donor 5. This was someone I met through Donor 4 and didn't have high hopes for at first, but he ended up being even more helpful than Donor 4. I used Donor 5 about a month prior to the procedure, in fact I tried this partly out of the possibility that it might improve my health enough to not need the procedure, but despite feeling the best I had in years it didn't. It may have had I been able to try Donor 5 earlier but that was not possible.
After the procedure and antibiotic course, I was worse than before the procedure, but not nearly all the way back to where I had been before starting oral transplants. At the time only Donor 4 was available, so I tried her again, and there was no benefit. Later when Donor 5 became available again I repeated with that donor and had a very comparable improvement to the first time I had used Donor 5. This is the only time in my entire history with transplants, FMT and oral, where a repeat treatment from the same donor without a change in composition (such as adding glycerol) had even close to as much benefit as the first treatment. And the only time where I had a treatment, lost benefit, retreated, and got it back. I haven't mentioned Donor 5 yet here for this reason, because I'm still in that critical period right now after the re-treatment, and the first time I didn't retain it long enough to fully judge the benefit.
So from this I conclude that 1 month is not long enough for a transplant to engraft well enough to resist short-term antibiotics, but 6 months is. This is consistent with the fact that after my OpenBiome treatment, the most rapid improvement was around the 5 week mark, and the start of the unraveling was around 6 weeks. These also suggest to me that anything under 2 months is "unsafe", and the transition is somewhere between 2 and 6 months.
So let me reiterate after all of this--taking antibiotics earlier than 2 months after a FMT, in hopes of improving the result, is almost certainly a bad idea. And doing it within just DAYS after a FMT, as in Michael's case, is a REALLY stupid idea! I don't mean to blame Michael for this--he was misinformed at the time. But we don't need to be now. And it's not JUST antibiotics, really any major change this early can ruin a result long-term.
It also means that Michael's Donor 4 (I'm not talking about mine), and possibly also Donor 3, may well have been significantly better donors than they seem to have been from his experiences. I had completely missed this on my first read through his reports on the 14 donors.
There are essentially four phases relative to microbiome transplants that I have ever taken antibiotics. When I talk about effects, I will be referring to short (2 week or less) courses unless stated otherwise. Long (6 months to a year or longer) courses are NEVER a good idea for the microbiome regardless of timing, and are rarely if ever prescribed by reputable doctors:
1. Months to years before any FMT.
Back before I had chronic health issues, these had some minor temporary side effects, but no lasting effects good or bad. At least no noticeable ones. Some studies have shown effects in lab animals like propensity toward obesity, so one cannot state with certainty that they are totally benign, but these are risk factors that only show up with large "n". I didn't have significant gut problems until after a long period of continuous antibiotics. After that point, multiple short courses of rifaximin did nothing at all. Michael noticed significant worsening during a short course near the beginning of his chronic illness journey, but minimal side effects, and some temporary improvement during later courses.
Thus, I'd say the "verdict" on this is, not chronically ill --> minimal overt effects, while chronically ill --> worsening until microbiome is "ruined", then no effect or a small, temporary benefit. It's worth mentioning the small group of people with near miraculous response to rifaximin, some of whom maintained it for months to years after, from the original SIBO studies. I suspect these were patients who had experienced relatively small and brief microbiome "insults", in fact it was common knowledge at the time that many of them had developed IBS following a bout of food poisoning, which is usually a few-day, self-limiting disease.
2. Immediately preceding a FMT.
This is what I have been calling "pretreatment". What distinguishes this from the previous is that there is not enough time for the microbiome to reach a new equilibrium after discontinuing the drug before new microbes are added in. This requires stoppage at most a week before FMT, probably less, but also at least 24 hours before FMT. Most common seems to be a 1-3 day gap. Also, nearly everyone uses vancomycin for this, not just "random" other antibiotics, and certainly not systemically absorbable ones, which could be important. And some protocols give a colon prep the day before FMT, which given the previous point likely helps flush out remaining antibiotic.
This is the timing that I have seen a significant number of researchers suggesting improves FMT. And it was what I did before my most successful FMT yet, in 2015.
Again, this is stopped prior to FMT. The minute you first introduce a new donor's microbes into your body, you are now in the third phase.
3. Immediately following a FMT (or other transplant). This includes in the middle of a multi-dose transplant.
Contrary to the previous phase, which is the most likely to be helpful, this is by far the most likely to be detrimental. And it's not just antibiotics that could be a problem here, really any unusual (for you) risky behavior is to be avoided. I suspect that after my first FMT an unraveling was instigated by relatively minor cannabis usage.
This is the vulnerable "critical period" that will determine how strong and lasting your success from a transplant will be. This is absolutely NOT the time to get impatient and "greedy", trying to desperately wring more benefit out of a transplant or accelerate the timeline of improvement. Even if you feel newly invincible from the transplant, you almost certainly aren't. Also it's too premature to judge the full extent of the benefit yet anyway, so the need for any further treatment isn't clear. I would recommend taking a several month complete hiatus from the field of medicine if it's possible. Unless your transplant actually made you WORSE--then by all means do whatever, because you're going to need more transplants later anyway.
So, to be brief, do not do this!
4. Long-term after a transplant
This applies to the experience when, approximately a year after my first and most successful FMT, a short course of rifaximin temporarily restored some of the benefit I had lost in the intervening year. Since this was the only course to show such a benefit, it suggests that it was only because some of the microbes from the FMT were still around, and that killing off some dysbiosis newly acquired in the intervening year allowed them to "show through". This strengthens my suspicion that the patients in the SIBO trials who improved had experienced damage too mild and brief to cause much "missing microbes".
The major question that remained after all of this was when the boundary is between phases 3 and 4. I may have partly narrowed this down inadvertently this year due to a minor surgical procedure I needed, that unfortunately required antibiotics. First there was an antibiotic drip during the procedure itself, I don't know what antibiotic I ended up getting (I could probably find out if it ends up being important). Then there was a 5-day course of TMP-SMX afterward, which I finished as directed. I would have preferred to avoid this procedure but I had an issue bad enough to affect lab results and not doing it could have caused long-term problems, of which I didn't need more.
This procedure was almost exactly 6 months after my first oral transplant from Donor 4, who you can read about here: https://forum.humanmicrobiome.info/threads/experience-so-far-with-oral-microbiome-transplant.1359/. In the intervening time I had tried a re-treatment with Donor 4, about 3 months after the first and three months prior to the procedure, with no further improvement. Also, a new donor entered the picture, Donor 5. This was someone I met through Donor 4 and didn't have high hopes for at first, but he ended up being even more helpful than Donor 4. I used Donor 5 about a month prior to the procedure, in fact I tried this partly out of the possibility that it might improve my health enough to not need the procedure, but despite feeling the best I had in years it didn't. It may have had I been able to try Donor 5 earlier but that was not possible.
After the procedure and antibiotic course, I was worse than before the procedure, but not nearly all the way back to where I had been before starting oral transplants. At the time only Donor 4 was available, so I tried her again, and there was no benefit. Later when Donor 5 became available again I repeated with that donor and had a very comparable improvement to the first time I had used Donor 5. This is the only time in my entire history with transplants, FMT and oral, where a repeat treatment from the same donor without a change in composition (such as adding glycerol) had even close to as much benefit as the first treatment. And the only time where I had a treatment, lost benefit, retreated, and got it back. I haven't mentioned Donor 5 yet here for this reason, because I'm still in that critical period right now after the re-treatment, and the first time I didn't retain it long enough to fully judge the benefit.
So from this I conclude that 1 month is not long enough for a transplant to engraft well enough to resist short-term antibiotics, but 6 months is. This is consistent with the fact that after my OpenBiome treatment, the most rapid improvement was around the 5 week mark, and the start of the unraveling was around 6 weeks. These also suggest to me that anything under 2 months is "unsafe", and the transition is somewhere between 2 and 6 months.
So let me reiterate after all of this--taking antibiotics earlier than 2 months after a FMT, in hopes of improving the result, is almost certainly a bad idea. And doing it within just DAYS after a FMT, as in Michael's case, is a REALLY stupid idea! I don't mean to blame Michael for this--he was misinformed at the time. But we don't need to be now. And it's not JUST antibiotics, really any major change this early can ruin a result long-term.
It also means that Michael's Donor 4 (I'm not talking about mine), and possibly also Donor 3, may well have been significantly better donors than they seem to have been from his experiences. I had completely missed this on my first read through his reports on the 14 donors.