Where are you getting information that genetic mutations can affect the length of stool? I'm not saying it isn't true, I just have never heard of such a thing. I can totally see changes in transit time, stool fat content, porphyrin metabolites (which cause the brown color), etc., I just wouldn't...
These two quotes of yours side by side get at the main issue. I see the first excerpt (before the dotted line) as being in direct conflict with the latter. Maybe not directly but there is a major conflict here in the implications.
Being part of a joint effort requires that one be amenable to...
I certainly saw the spreadsheet, in fact I analyzed it in detail after you posted this so that I would be able to illustrate what I was referring to. In particular, I looked at both the amount of increase or decrease in health status out of 10 from pre- to post-FMT for each recipient for both...
It's really interesting to me that this got into Nature--there's a whole literature dating back decades of study of chemical reactions at water interfaces with other materials involving combined simulation and experiment like this, but the vast majority of it is in quite niche journals limited...
There is so much to say here, that's why I haven't replied yet because I've been thinking how to say it without it getting too incredibly long.
Sorry to break it to you if you haven't noticed already, but pretty much everywhere except from on this forum, HM is practically a non-entity. If it's...
Where did you get the information that stool length has any bearing at all? I haven't seen anything about that on the wiki or in previous forum threads here. I'd also suspect that length of stool pieces has at least as much to do with the donor's defecation habits (i.e. how much they "push"...
As I said, ALL donors from GD are high Firmicutes (both DF3 and DF7, who I used, but who are no longer offered by them, were as well), as measured by their testing lab in the Netherlands. I wouldn't be so sure that actually means that they are opposite of what you were, unless you had yours...
You can get an idea of F/B ratio by looking at the microbiome report, under "Your Composition" and changing the level to "Phylum". However, note that different testing methods give different, incompatible values for this ratio, such that you can only really compare within a test provider. The...
In that case it really isn't relevant to the question of whether this is a good quality donor or not. And see my second paragraph above.
Unfortunately our understanding of the microbiome is not to the point where we would know any better which microbes are most compatible with or important to...
Two issues:
1. Are we talking about the donor or the recipient here?
2. What is more relevant for the recipient than the "root" cause is the most modifiable contributor.
With regards to the donor, it doesn't really matter whether the root cause is genetic, or whether the microbiome was altered...
Exactly. The fact that he doesn't even see fit to address serious concerns others have about the ethics of his business (despite being extremely harsh on OTHER businesses) speaks volumes about where his priorities are.
If someone actually solved the problem of who has the healthiest...
Yes exactly.
The difference between the early symptoms and the stretching sensation was that the early symptoms were relatively constant while they existed, but temporary, lasting only a day or two of the treatment, whereas the gut stretching came on immediately after each new dose and was...
Three days is probably too short, I find that it takes around 5 days for almost any change (dietary, antibiotics, etc.) to reach its full impact on the gut, sometimes to have any impact. Occasionally before that there's somewhat of a "die-off" type reaction, where I feel more tired, have a bit...