Recent content by SFBayFMT5

  1. S

    Vagina Vaginal microbiota transplantation for treatment of vaginal dysbiosis without the use of antibiotics: a double-blind, randomised controlled trial in women with vaginal dysbiosis (Mar 2026, n=49) "VMT without antibiotics did not significantly improve microbiome conversion in this trial"

    I love the statement that the one pregnancy that occurred was "unrelated to treatment" :-) I'm not sure how well-established it is in fact that all women with a more diverse vaginal microbiome are at risk for reproductive complications. It is well-known that the diversity is correlated with...
  2. S

    Other What is the public perception of FMT? How much does it matter? Has it been blocking progress?

    For most people in the medical field, the risk/benefit analysis looks very different than from the POV of a desperate patient, or even a dispassionate scientist studying the microbiome in an abstract and/or theoretical manner. Their entire worldview is unfortunately clouded by thoughts of...
  3. S

    Other Popularity and acceptance of FMT. Who is to blame for why FMT will never be available? Ignorance, laziness, and apathy of the general public? How to motivate people to take action?

    As far as I know, what first happened (at least in modern times) is doctors trying FMT for their patients in what were effectively informal clinical trials, when those patients had something like C. diff where there was no known cure that worked for the patients. At the time, since so few people...
  4. S

    Other Popularity and acceptance of FMT. Who is to blame for why FMT will never be available? Ignorance, laziness, and apathy of the general public? How to motivate people to take action?

    You don't specify who "these companies" are, but I'm guessing you mean just general companies that are successful doing business in the US. I don't think you can compare FMT marketing to selling of something like computer games, AI, "life hack" gadgets, vacation rentals, or anything like that...
  5. S

    FMT Gut microbiota modulation via repeated donor fecal transplantation improves motor and gastrointestinal symptoms in drug-naïve Parkinson’s disease: a randomized phase 2 trial (Mar 2026, n=72)

    That's the first time I've seen mention of placing a GI catheter to allow repeated FMTs through a colonoscopy-like route. Clearly, having repeat colonoscopies seven days in a row each month for three months would never be allowed, and I guess for whatever reason they did NOT want to use capsules...
  6. S

    Other Popularity and acceptance of FMT. Who is to blame for why FMT will never be available? Ignorance, laziness, and apathy of the general public? How to motivate people to take action?

    I think this is exactly it. And even people who are possibly worse in terms of objective sickness (if you can even measure that) are often sick in more visible and empathizable, "socially acceptable" ways, and see less of a gap between their current ability level and where they could be at if...
  7. S

    10-year-old Emma puts severe Ulcerative Colitis in remission with DIY FMT from her mom (2013)

    It's great that it worked so quickly for her. She's also lucky that doctors were already willing to help this family out and recommend FMT back in 2014. It's also a shame that someone her age was so sick already.
  8. S

    Other Sleep disruption damages gut's self-repair ability via stress signals from brain (Feb 2026) Sleep disturbance triggers aberrant activation of vagus circuitry and induces intestinal stem cell dysfunction

    It's interesting here that increased serotonin is part of the pathology. This possibly has some relevance to people whose gut gets worse on SSRIs. My descent into the worst gut problems I've ever had started after being on 5-HTP for a little over 2 years. It was much worse even than where I...
  9. S

    Healthcare system Incoming trump admin with RFK signals new start for FDA

    From 00:35:20 in Casey Means' hearing: "The science is showing us, through amazing work in systems biology and network biology, that the physiologic causes of the vast majority of diseases... are connected by shared physiology and shared root causes." Then from 00:45:20: Dr. Jay Bhattacharya...
  10. S

    Genetics New Study Links Gut Makeup to Celiac Disease Pathogenesis (Feb 2026, n=12,652) The HUNT study identifies host genetic factors reproducibly associated with human gut microbiota composition

    This seems like a very weak study, identifying a single bacterium that correlates with celiac disease and no attempt to follow it up to determine causality.
  11. S

    Sources Comparing commercial FMT providers

    That IS sketchy. You may be wondering why I'm saying that now, given that I didn't consider it fishy when I learned he had neglected to inform me that one recipient had had a negative response to one donor. The difference is if it is a pattern. I take it for granted that for every provider of...
  12. S

    STICKY General meta discussion #001, July 2023. For questions and feedback that don't need their own thread

    Thanks! I assumed that since I explained the background of the research and summarized the methods that including the abstract wasn't necessary. Now I know, I will paste the abstract in a quote if and when that research gets published in a regular journal.
  13. S

    STICKY General meta discussion #001, July 2023. For questions and feedback that don't need their own thread

    You really need to be clearer about which rules/guidelines posts don't conform to. I know the guidelines are there, and I read through them every time before making a post, but apparently there are some I occasionally miss. On other forums, the rules are numbered, and posts that violate one of...
  14. S

    Other Duplicating FMT, stool donor, and microbiome projects vs solving existing barriers

    I see it more as a case of "when all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail". Aim for NaN has coding skills, and can handle the web design better than most people, so that's where the focus goes, rather than looking for where the actual "weakest link" is in the process (which has...
  15. S

    Other Duplicating FMT, stool donor, and microbiome projects vs solving existing barriers

    I what way do you think that lack of coding expertise had anything to do with why HM was so difficult to start up? As I understand it, the barriers are: 1. Reaching out to quality donor candidates--i.e. the initial contact. A website might be coded perfectly and be very user-friendly, but if...
Back
Top Bottom